Castaway Key Real Estate

There are 3 active listings in Castaway Key, Captiva, with a median asking price of $130,000 and an average of 62 days on market.

Active Listings

Median Asking Price

$130,000

Average Asking Price

$139,517

Avg. Days on Market

About Castaway Key

Castaway Key is a Southwest Florida community in Captiva where the NABOR MLS currently shows 3 active listings, asking $130,000 to $158,550, averaging 62 days on market. Waterfront Realty Group, Inc. has worked this market as an independent, Realtor-owned brokerage since 1986, and pairs every customer with a Sales Associate who knows these streets, waterways, and price trends firsthand.

Figures reflect the active Castaway Key inventory shown on this page, drawn live from the Naples Area Board of REALTORS® (NABOR) MLS. Closed-sale counts cover the trailing 90 days.

Available Properties

Castaway Key Listings

3 properties shown

$158,550

4520 Cutlass DR

Listing courtesy of Sellstate 5 Star Realty

Source: NABOR MLS

$130,000

4471 Smugglers DR

Listing courtesy of The Keyes Company

Source: NABOR MLS

$130,000

4520 Smugglers DR

Listing courtesy of The Keyes Company

Source: NABOR MLS

Listing data provided via the Naples Area Board of REALTORS® (NABOR) MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Equal Housing Opportunity. © 2026 Waterfront Realty Group, Inc. License CQ257718. All rights reserved.

Get in touch

Interested in Castaway Key?

A local Sales Associate with firsthand knowledge of Castaway Key will reach out within 24 hours.